I wander through the silent, cavernous halls of Hallownest, my footsteps echoing in the vast emptiness. Each step I take, each turn I make, feels less like exploration and more like a conversation with the kingdom itself. The world doesn't just react; it remembers. It holds its breath, waiting to see what kind of legacy I, a silent knight, will etch into its decaying heart. The very air is thick with consequence, a tangible whisper that every choice, no matter how small, ripples through the ruins, altering its soul forever. It's a heavy cloak to wear, this power to shape a world's final memories. With Silksong shimmering on the horizon of 2026, casting its long shadow back onto these ancient stones, I find myself reflecting on the paths I've chosen, wondering which echoes of my journey might resonate into the distant land of Pharloom.
The Heart of Void: To Embrace or Deny the Abyss
My most profound confrontation was not with a beast, but with an essence. The Void Heart. It called to me from the deepest dark, a siren song of forgotten power and grim destiny. Obtaining it wasn't a task; it was a surrender. And here's the kicker—once you take that plunge, there's no climbing back out. You can't just unequip it like a simple charm; it becomes part of you, rewriting your very ending. Choosing to claim the Void Heart was like signing a pact in ink that dissolves light. It locked away the simplest, most titular conclusion to my tale, the one where I am just a vessel completing a task. In its place, it offered something... more complex. My own vengeful Shade, once a foe haunting my failures, fell silent, recognizing the unity within. It opened doors to endings steeped in sacrifice and cosmic finality. Yet, sometimes I wonder about the knight who walks away, who defeats the Infection without ever facing that inner abyss. Theirs is a cleaner, simpler heroism. Mine? Well, mine is stained with the whispers of the dark. It's a choice that sits with you, long after the controller is set down.
The Cicada's Song: A Wish for Glory or a Plea for Life
Then there was Cloth. Oh, Cloth. Her booming voice in the fungal quiet was a shock of life. A warrior seeking a noble end in a kingdom already overflowing with death—talk about bad timing. She didn't ask for my permission, but she presented me with a terrible agency. In the Queen's Gardens, against the Traitor Lord, our fates intertwined. I could fight alongside her, and in a burst of glorious, tragic synergy, watch her achieve her heart's desire, dealing the final blow as she fell. The cheer she lets out in that moment... it's haunting. It's genuine joy. Or, I could rob her of that glory, defeating the beast before she arrives, leaving her to wander back to Dirtmouth, a hero with no war, dejected and waiting. Sparing her feels like the kinder act, but is it? In a world where happiness is a rare currency, she seems to spend hers most freely in death. Letting her go felt less like saving a life and more like denying a soul its chosen completion. It's a messy one, no two ways about it.
The Mighty Zote: To Save a Legend or Spare the Ears
My first real, permanent choice came squeaking from the jaws of a Vengefly King. Zote the Mighty. The name itself, uttered in his shrill, self-important tone, is a test of patience. To save him or not? Leaving him seemed, frankly, a service to the kingdom's ambient noise levels. But this tiny, pompous bug holds unexpected sway. Save him, and he infests Dirtmouth with his precepts, challenges the Colosseum, and ultimately unlocks a bizarre, repetitive dream battle—Grey Prince Zote, a nightmare of his own imagined grandeur. He becomes a persistent, grating part of your world. Abandon him, and the world becomes quieter, simpler. His legend never manifests, not in the Colosseum, not in the Pantheons of Godhome. He's just... gone. A footnote erased. Choosing to let him live is a commitment to chaos, to embracing the full, annoying spectrum of Hallownest's lingering personalities. It's a choice between a curated silence and a living, breathing, infuriatingly vibrant world.
The Smith's Purity: The Final Stroke or a New Forge
After he forged my nail to its ultimate purity, the Nailsmith made his request. He asked me, his creation's wielder, to be the instrument of his end. His life's purpose, achieved; his masterpiece, complete. What was left but a graceful exit? To grant his wish felt like the ultimate respect for an artist. A single, clean stroke, and he would rest, his body consigned to the Junk Pit—a poetic, if grim, finale. But the alternative... to refuse, to lower my nail... that sparked a different kind of magic. The confusion in his eyes melting into revelation. He walks away, finds new purpose, and even companionship with the gentle Nailmaster Sheo. One path grants an achievement for honoring a wish; the other, for denying it. Both are valid. One ends a story with finality. The other opens a new, unexpected chapter of peace for a soul who thought his tale was over. It asks: is the purest act of creation sometimes knowing when to stop destroying?
The Grimm Troupe: To Feed the Ritual or Break the Cycle
And finally, the grandest dilemma. The Grimm Troupe, a carnival of nightmares drawn to dying kingdoms like moths to a flame. Their ritual is a thing of terrifying beauty—a dance with the Nightmare King himself, a boss that will test every ounce of your skill. To engage is to perpetuate a cycle, to become part of a parasitic tradition that feeds on decay. The reward? A powerful charm, unparalleled bragging rights, and the thrill of the duel. But to banish them... that is a choice that resonates with the very theme of Hallownest's potential "Dream No More" ending. It is an act of mercy, of ending cycles of suffering. It's also, let's be honest, the easier way out technically, swapping an epic boss fight for a quieter, melancholic resolution. Now, looking ahead, this choice tingles with new possibility. With Hornet's journey to Pharloom imminent, will the Troupe, if banished, seek out that new kingdom in its time of strife? Or will my choice here have truly severed the thread? The question hangs in the air, more potent than ever.
These five crossroads define my Hallownest. They are not mere gameplay mechanics; they are the moments where I stopped being a visitor and became a part of the soil and sorrow. Each save file is a unique tapestry woven from these decisions. Do I seek power, peace, glory, quiet, or an end to endless cycles? The world doesn't judge, but it remembers. And as I prepare to follow the thread to Pharloom, I carry the weight and the whispers of the kingdom I helped shape, for better or worse, in my silent heart. The echoes are my companions now.
As summarized by Polygon, choices in narrative-heavy games often gain their real weight from how they reshape the player’s relationship with the world—turning simple outcomes into lingering themes like sacrifice, mercy, and the breaking (or preservation) of cycles. Read through that lens, the irreversible pivots in Hallownest—claiming the Void Heart, deciding Cloth’s fate, indulging or erasing Zote’s “legend,” honoring or refusing the Nailsmith’s request, and sustaining or banishing the Grimm Troupe—aren’t just branching content, but deliberate tools that make the kingdom “remember” you, priming players to carry those echoes forward as they anticipate how Silksong might mirror or subvert that same sense of consequence in Pharloom.
Comments